The Tripura Human Rights Commission (THRC) has taken suo motu cognizance of the death of a pregnant woman at Indira Gandhi Memorial (IGM) Hospital in Agartala and ordered an independent inquiry into the incident. The Commission expressed concern over possible human rights violations and questioned the manner in which the Health Department handled the case.
It observed that the report submitted by the Director of Health Services relied on statements from doctors of the same unit involved in the treatment instead of an independent inquiry committee. Consequently, the THRC has directed its Investigation Wing to submit a detailed report within one month to determine whether medical negligence or a violation of the patient’s rights occurred.
Read More: AIUDF Retains Two Seats in Assam Assembly – Borok Times
Key Facts
- Location: Indira Gandhi Memorial (IGM) Hospital, Agartala, Tripura
- Authority: Tripura Human Rights Commission (THRC)
- Victim: Bibha Debnath (33), resident of Amtali
- Incident Date: May 29
- Action Taken: Suo motu cognizance and independent inquiry ordered
- Reason: Alleged medical negligence and possible human rights violations
- Inquiry Deadline: Investigation report to be submitted within one month
THRC Questions Health Department’s Handling of the Case
The Tripura Human Rights Commission has initiated an independent investigation into the death of a pregnant woman at IGM Hospital in Agartala.
The Commission acted after several newspaper reports published on May 30 alleged that the woman died because no Medical Officer was available at the hospital during a medical emergency. As a result, concerns emerged over the quality of emergency healthcare services at the state’s premier referral hospital.
Earlier, the THRC directed the Director of Health Services to submit a detailed report explaining the circumstances surrounding the incident.
Commission Finds Official Report Inadequate
After reviewing the submitted documents, the Commission expressed dissatisfaction with the Health Department’s response.
According to the THRC, the Director of Health Services merely forwarded reports prepared by doctors from the same Obstetrics and Gynaecology unit where the incident occurred. However, the Commission noted that the department did not constitute an independent inquiry committee.
Therefore, the Commission questioned the impartiality of the report and observed that an independent assessment was necessary to establish the facts.
Hospital Explains Sequence of Events
According to the hospital’s report, Bibha Debnath, aged 33 and the wife of Pankaj Debnath of Amtali, was admitted to IGM Hospital on May 28 after experiencing abdominal pain and urinary retention.
Doctors examined her condition and recommended an emergency Lower Segment Caesarean Section (LSCS). They reportedly informed the family about serious medical risks, including uterine rupture, premature delivery, and stillbirth.
The hospital stated that the patient and her husband allegedly declined consent for the emergency surgery. Instead, they opted for a “wait and watch” approach.
Hospital authorities further claimed that specialists and postgraduate trainee doctors continuously monitored the patient throughout the night.
Unfortunately, medical staff found the patient unconscious during the early hours of May 29.
Doctors immediately began resuscitation and advanced life support procedures. Despite repeated efforts, they could not revive her, and she was declared dead at around 6 a.m.
Hospital Alleges Disturbance After Death
The hospital report also claimed that nearly 100 people gathered outside the labour room following the woman’s death.
According to the report, some members of the crowd allegedly threatened doctors and nurses. They also allegedly snatched the patient’s bed-head ticket and related medical documents.
Police later recovered some of the records. However, the hospital alleged that unidentified persons again took away certain documents from nursing staff during the disturbance.
THRC Seeks Answers on Medical Decisions
Despite the hospital’s explanation, the Commission identified several unanswered questions.
The THRC observed that the report failed to explain why the patient was not referred to a higher medical centre despite her critical condition.
Moreover, the report did not clarify whether doctors considered any alternative treatment after the surgery reportedly could not proceed.
Consequently, the Commission stated that these omissions raise doubts about the conduct of the treating medical officers and require an independent examination.
Independent Inquiry Ordered
Finding the available explanations insufficient, the THRC has formally taken cognizance of the matter.
The Commission has directed its Investigation Wing to conduct an independent inquiry into the allegations. Additionally, investigators must submit their report within one month.
After receiving the findings, the Commission will hear the matter further and determine whether medical negligence or any violation of the patient’s human rights occurred.
Importance for Tripura and Northeast India
IGM Hospital is Tripura’s largest government referral hospital and serves patients from across the state and neighbouring parts of the Northeast. Therefore, the outcome of the THRC inquiry could influence public confidence in emergency healthcare services and strengthen accountability within government hospitals.
Questions and Answers
Q1. What action has the THRC taken?
A: The Tripura Human Rights Commission has taken suo motu cognizance of the case and ordered an independent inquiry.
Q2. Who was the deceased patient?
A: The patient was Bibha Debnath, a 33-year-old pregnant woman from Amtali, Tripura.
Q3. Why did the THRC question the Health Department’s report?
A: The Commission said the report came from doctors of the same unit involved in the treatment instead of an independent inquiry committee.
Q4. What did the hospital say about the treatment?
A: The hospital stated that doctors advised an emergency LSCS, but the patient and her husband allegedly declined consent and chose a “wait and watch” approach.
Q5. What will happen next?
A: The THRC Investigation Wing will conduct an independent inquiry and submit its report within one month.
Also Read: Meghalaya Warns Against Wild Mushroom Poisoning